Skip to content

Alternatives & Comparison

HelloCounsel vs Arctrieval for Personal Injury Firms

One gives your records team better software. The other makes the follow-up calls for them. Here's how to tell which your firm needs.

Book a Demo
Suchana Naskar
6 min read
Side-by-side comparison of HelloCounsel and Arctrieval for PI medical records
Key takeaway
  • Arctrieval reports 90% of records within 30 days on its method, with the rest typically in 45 to 60 days. See Arctrieval FAQ.
  • Firms running HelloCounsel's Medical Records agent have cut 15 days from records turnaround.
  • Disclosure: HelloCounsel publishes this comparison.

Arctrieval is records request software your staff runs: it prepares and sends requests, sends reminders and tracks status, for a flat monthly fee by user. HelloCounsel is an AI agent that follows up with providers by phone, email and fax, and logs every attempt in your case file. Choose Arctrieval to organize requests; choose HelloCounsel to offload the chasing.

How do HelloCounsel and Arctrieval compare?

The two products solve different halves of the records problem. Arctrieval makes requests consistent and cheap to send, using patient access requests and automatic reminders. HelloCounsel handles what happens when a provider doesn't answer: the calls, phone trees, hold queues and re-submissions. Some firms use both.

HelloCounselArctrieval
What it isAI agents that place and follow up on requestsSoftware your staff uses to request and manage records
Who follows up with a silent providerThe agent, by phone, email and faxAutomatic emails and notices; escalation calls by your staff
Works phone trees and hold queuesYesNo
Request methodYour firm's existing authorizations and processPatient right-of-access requests (45 CFR 164.524)
Published turnaround15 days cut from turnaround90% within 30 days on its method
Pricing modelCustom by volume, no per-minute billingFlat monthly by number of users, unlimited requests
Invoices and prepaymentTasks the right person when an invoice is dueProviders invoice you; disputed-invoice guidance published
Case managementLogs every attempt in your case fileClio, Filevine, Litify, SmartAdvocate, Smokeball; MyCase, CasePeer, Neos coming
Other callsAlso answers reception, intake and case opening callsRecords only
Best forFirms whose records desk is stuck on the phoneFirms that want cheap, organized requests run in-house

Sources: Arctrieval's FAQ, checked 16 November 2026; HelloCounsel product pages.

Who chases the provider that doesn't respond?

With Arctrieval, the software sends reminders at set intervals, such as day 3, day 15 and day 30, and your staff make the escalation calls. With HelloCounsel, the agent calls the records desk, works the phone tree, waits on hold and re-submits lost requests. That difference decides how many staff hours records still take.

If your team already has time for the calls, Arctrieval's reminders may be enough. If the calls are what's falling behind, see medical records follow-up vs retrieval for how firms split the work.

How does pricing compare?

Arctrieval charges a flat monthly subscription based on users, with unlimited requests and fax overages at $0.06 a page. HelloCounsel uses custom pricing based on volume, with no per-minute billing, at about a quarter of what retrieval companies charge. Neither charges per request, so costs stay steadier as your docket grows.

With both, providers still bill copy fees directly, and those fees vary by state and request type. See medical records fees by state.

Should a PI firm choose HelloCounsel or Arctrieval?

Choose Arctrieval if your requests are disorganized or expensive and your staff have time for escalation calls. Choose HelloCounsel if requests go out fine but sit with providers, and your team spends hours on hold. Firms with heavy records volume often run both: Arctrieval for requests, HelloCounsel for the calls.

Arctrieval is the better fit when

  • You want the lowest-cost way to send organized requests.
  • Your team is comfortable making escalation calls.
  • You use a CMS Arctrieval already integrates with.

HelloCounsel is the better fit when

  • Providers don't answer and follow-up calls fall behind.
  • You want status in your case file after every attempt.
  • You also need help with reception, intake or case opening calls.

What's the difference between a patient access request and an attorney authorization?

A patient access request is the client exercising their own HIPAA right to their records, which gives the provider 30 days to act, with one 30-day extension. An attorney request under a signed HIPAA authorization is a third-party disclosure, with timing set mostly by state law. Arctrieval uses the first route; many firms still use the second.

Patient access requestHIPAA authorization to the firm
Rule45 CFR 164.52445 CFR 164.508
Who is askingThe client, for their own recordsThe firm, with the client's signed permission
Federal response deadline30 days, plus one 30-day extensionNone in HIPAA; state law may set one
Typical useArctrieval's default methodMost firms' standard request

Both routes still depend on the provider answering, which is where follow-up calls come in. For what a request needs so it isn't rejected, see attorney request for medical records. The authorization rule itself is 45 CFR 164.508.

How does HelloCounsel's Medical Records agent work?

The agent picks up a records task, submits the request, then confirms it landed by calling the records desk. It follows up by phone, email and fax on your cadence, re-submits lost requests, and tasks the right person when an invoice is due. Every attempt is logged in the case file.

Medical Records agent pricing: Custom pricing

Based on your volume, with no per-minute billing. HIPAA compliant.

Schedule Demo

What do firms say about working with HelloCounsel?

"Working with HelloCounsel has been an outstanding experience. Their commitment to client service and innovation is evident in everything they do." — Anthony Ramos, COO, Pendergast Law

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Arctrieval or HelloCounsel cheaper?

Neither publishes exact plan prices. Arctrieval charges a flat monthly fee by user with unlimited requests. HelloCounsel prices on volume with no per-minute billing. Compare them on total cost including staff hours: the cheaper tool on paper may leave more calls with your team.

Does Arctrieval call providers?

Arctrieval's published workflow sends requests and reminders by email, fax and mail. Escalation calls to providers are made by your own staff, with an Office for Civil Rights complaint as the last resort for providers that don't comply. How many of those calls your team can make decides how fast records arrive.

Does HelloCounsel summarize medical records?

No. HelloCounsel's agent gets records in by following up with providers and logging every attempt. It doesn't review, summarize or build chronologies. Firms that need summaries pair it with a review tool. HelloCounsel focuses on the calls, emails and faxes that get the records into the file in the first place.

Can a firm use HelloCounsel and Arctrieval together?

Yes. Arctrieval can send and track the requests while HelloCounsel's agent makes the follow-up calls to providers that haven't answered. Agree which system holds request status so the team works from one record. Usually that is your case management system, so anyone on the case can see what is still outstanding.

Related

Stop chasing providers by hand

See how the Medical Records agent follows up for you.

Book a demo

Share this article

Subscribe to
our newsletter